Top 12 Covers of 2011

Top 12 Covers from 2011Inspired by NPR’s 5 Great Cover Songs from 2011, here are my top 12 covers from 2011 — starting with two of the hardest-rocking, and ending with the quietest ones.

1)    Like a Prayer   Grace Potter & The Nocturnals      6:23

This cover of Madonna’s 1989 hit comes from Grace Potter & The NocturnalsiTunes Session EP, which also includes a cover of the Beatles’ “Dear Prudence.”

2)    Get Back   The Jim Jones Revue      2:40

This Beatles cover appears on Burning Your House Down, a title which nicely describes the band‘s explosive  thrash/punk/rockabilly sound.  Wow.  The intensity knocks me over.  Here they are performing “High Horse” (an original) on Letterman in September.

3)    Tubthumping   They Might Be Giants feat. the Onion AV Club Choir      3:22

Recorded for the Onion AV Club earlier this year, They Might Be Giants‘ cover of Chumbawumba’s 1997 pop hit appears on the TMBG b-sides compilation, Album Raises New and Troubling Questions.

4)    99 Problems / Can’t Tell Me Nothing   Aloe Blacc      2:47

Aloe Blacc‘s soulful cover of Jay-Z’s “99 Problems” (cleaned up for radio), which pulls in Kanye West’s “Can’t Tell Me Nothing” and James Brown’s “The Big Payback.”   He performed the song on BBC Radio 1′s Live Lounge.

5)    Price Tag   The Wombats      4:16

The Wombats cover Jessie J’s big hit, described by lead vocalist Matthew Murphy as “a massive bulletproof pop song with quite a nice sentiment.”  I’m a big Wombats fan — if you don’t have their two LPs, well, what are you waiting for?

6)    Hard Bargain   Emmylou Harris      3:23

Such a beautiful cover of Ron Sexsmith‘s song, which originally appears on his Retriever (2004). Emmylou Harris likes the song so much that she also used it for the title of her album.  She could sing almost anything and make it sound transcendent, but when she sings a song that’s already a good one — well, just give it a listen, eh?

7)    When U Love Somebody   The Decemberists      3:11

This doesn’t actually stray that far from the Fruit Bats‘ original version, but there’s something about the Decemberists‘ ragged intensity that keeps bringing me back to their recording.  It appears on their iTunes Session EP.

8)    I Want You Back   Sonos      1:46

Beautiful, melancholic version of the Jackson 5′s 1969 smash hit.  Sonos were one of the best groups on NBC’s The Sing-Off, sent home early for being a bit too experimental in their interpretations.  That willingness to experiment, however, is precisely what made them — and Afro-Blue (another group that should have been a finalist) — so great.  But the judges didn’t get it.  Sonos also recorded a longer version of this for their 2009 record SONOSings.  The version here comes from The Sing-Off: Season 3, Episode 4.

9)    Take Five   Sachal Studios Orchestra      5:52

An “Eastern” version of Dave Brubeck’s classic, recorded in Lahore, Pakistan by the Sachal Studios Orchestra.

10) White Rabbit (Live on Fresh Air)   Gillian Welch      2:59

Gillian Welch and David Rawlings offer their version of the Jefferson Airplane song.  If you’re a fan of Gillian Welch, Terry Gross’s Fresh Air interview is well worth your while.

11) Don’t Fence Me In   Daniel Johnson and Brie Stoner      3:43

There’s a version of this on iTunes, but this is the recording you see in the video below… because I like this version better.  Johnson and Stoner originally recorded their version of this Cole Porter classic for a Nokia advertisement.

12) I’m Going to Go Back There Someday   Rachael Yamagata      4:16

Very nearly all of the covers on the Green Album (new versions of songs that feature in Muppet programs) are great, but I’m particularly fond of this one.  Gonzo the Great brings some pathos to the original version, but Rachel Yamagata singing “There isn’t a word yet for old friends who’ve just met” should touch the heart of even the crustiest curmudgeon.  (Yes, I’m talking to you, Statler and Waldorf!)

4 Comments »

  1. Libby Said,

    December 20, 2011 @ 10:57 am

    OK, I was not a big fan of that particular cover of “I Want You Back” when I heard it on The SIng-Off, but I’m liking it better now. (My favorite of that one is Katie Tunstall’s, though). I also wanted to defend the judges on The Sing-Off–I do think Pentatonix was the best group, though Afro-Blue and Sonos were both great. Reading Ben Folds’ blog about how they made their decision was really interesting–he said right out that Afro-Blue was his favorite group all year. And a lot of these groups do go on to do really well even if they don’t win, which I think is great.

    (Sorry, I just love that show!)

  2. Philip Nel Said,

    December 20, 2011 @ 12:44 pm

    I’m a Sing-Off fan, too. I concur that Pentatonix was the best, though I wanted Afro-Blue to rank higher (certainly top 3). And one thing I like about this “I Want You Back” is that the minor key brings out the melancholy and longing in the lyrics. It’s a transformative cover, reminding us that this usually uptempo pop song harbors some sadness. I need to check out that blog post — I read some of Ben Folds’ blog posts, but not all of them (and certainly not this one).

  3. Scott Rader Said,

    December 26, 2011 @ 9:11 am

    99 Problems is by Jay-Z, not Kanye, but this is a good list.

  4. Philip Nel Said,

    December 26, 2011 @ 10:42 am

    Thanks, Scott. And how embarrassing. I know full well that “99 Problems” is on Jay-Z’s Black Album. Should’ve proofread this more carefully. Have made the correction. If you see other errors, please don’t hesitate to point them out.

Leave a Comment