Syd Hoff’s Teeth: The Leftist Satire of A. Redfield

Redfield's The Ruling Clawss (1935): title pageWhile he was contributing to the New Yorker as Syd Hoff, he was also contributing to the Daily Worker and New Masses as A. Redfield — the pseudonym he adopted for his radical work.  The Ruling Clawss (Daily Worker, 1935) collects his cartoons originally published in the Communist daily.  Contrary to what all published biographies (except for the one in Julia Mickenberg’s and my Tales for Little Rebels) allege, Hoff’s first collection of cartoons was not Feeling No Pain (Dial, 1944).  His first such collection — and, in fact, his first published book — was The Ruling Clawss.  Here are a few selections.

Redfield's The Ruling Clawss (1935): "I wish mother would let me live like that for six months so I could write a novel."

Hoff mocks this bourgeois “artist” as a voyeur with no understanding of true suffering.

Redfield's The Ruling Clawss (1935): "... we who turn the wheels of industry ..."

This wealthy, well-fed speaker attempts to align himself with the workers.  He’s also oblivious to how thoroughly he is failing.  The workers’ stony expressions make that failure quite clear to us, though.

Redfield's The Ruling Clawss (1935): "Anybody who says there's starvation in America ought to have his head examined."

If you tuned in to Fox News during the presidency of George W. Bush, you would have heard sentiments similar to those expressed above.

Redfield's The Ruling Clawss (1935): "Give him a nickel, sweetheart. After all, you made a couple of million on the war."

In what may be the most acid cartoon in The Ruling Clawss, Hoff aims at those who profit from war, but remain indifferent to its human costs.

Redfield's Ruling Clawss (1935): "I'm against unemployment insurance — it would make people lazy"

Hoff attacks the still-current conservative argument that suffering is somehow ennobling or motivating.  Only someone who has never suffered could make such a claim.

Redfield's Ruling Clawss (1935): "Aren't you exaggerating just a little bit, Mr. Redfield?"

In “Social Satire,” an essay by Hoff (as Redfield) included as an afterword, the artist argues that most contemporary satirists are not sharp enough: “Today we have a new group of satirists who, at the same time that they bite the bourgeoisie, use only their lips, but not their teeth” (180).  He singles out Peter Arno, Otto Soglow (The Little King), Harold Gray (Little Orphan Annie), Sidney Smith (The Gumps), Chester Gould (Dick Tracy), and Percy Crosby (Skippy) for particular criticism.  He praises only Art Young, “the greatest satirist of his day.”  Everyone else falls short.  They “are talented and funny, but . . . their comedy is all too often a whitewash for people and conditions that, in reality, are not funny” (183).

Hoff (1912-2004) was something of a renaissance man in the field of cartooning.  He wrote syndicated comic strips, satirical cartoons (both with and without teeth), children’s books, and even a 400-page illustrated history of political cartooning.  All told, he was the author, illustrator, or author-illustrator of over 100 books.  Only a few of those books betray the political commitment of his youth — notably, Gentleman Jim and the Great John L (1977) and Boss Tweed and the Man Who Drew Him (1978).  The latter book is about Thomas Nast, another satirist who — like Hoff — created art that, sometimes, sunk sharp teeth into the powerful.

Redfield's Ruling Clawss (1935): left endpaper Redfield's Ruling Clawss (1935): right endpaper

Related posts:

27 Comments »

  1. Balloon Juice » Cartoons for Sully Said,

    February 19, 2011 @ 1:28 pm

    [...] 1930’s “The Ruling Clawss” was a series of cartoons that New Yorker cartoonist Syd Hoff published in the Daily Worker under the pen name A. Redfield. As the Daily Worker was Communist paper we must take a moment to [...]

  2. unemployedhack Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 7:26 am

    Thanks for this. They’re excellent satirical cartoons perfectly capturing the global situation today: the continuing problem of the ruling class and its lack of perspective. I hadn’t seen them before and I’m very glad I have now.

  3. millie fink Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 8:23 am

    Thanks, excellent stuff. Would that the New Yorker had this kind of guts today!

    Hoff would’ve had a field day with that foreclosing law firm that held a Homeless Halloween party. It’s such a good example of the kind of disconnect he illustrated in in comics.

  4. TAJ Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 8:52 am

    What wonderful reminders that society fluctuates but rarely changes. The veteran beggar/war profiteer cartoon is a particularly potent (and sad) commentary. Thanks so much for posting!

  5. The Leftist Satire of A. Redfield - Southern Maryland Community Forums Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 9:22 am

    [...] Leftist Satire of A. Redfield Link to original article. "While he was contributing to the New Yorker as Syd Hoff, he was also contributing to the [...]

  6. barf Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 10:08 am

    history repeats itself…

  7. Fred Pfister Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 11:45 am

    Good satire is timeless. It may become out of date for a spell, but the human condition and man’s propensity to repeat the mistakes of history will invariable make it “in” and relevant again.

  8. Ben Thompson Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 12:54 pm

    Regarding the cartoon about starvation where all the people seated around the table are very overweight and fat as opposed to the poor back then who were skinny from lack of food.
    Today it is the poor that are usually obese and the wealthy are thin because they can afford to go to the gym or have a trainer.

  9. Bill the Splut Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 2:38 pm

    Note the legless veteran’s eyes–blind, from mustard gas. Just like the last 10 years, “SUPPORT THE TROOPS!” is just a bludgeon to shut up people against war. They really mean “SUPPORT THE TROOPS–as political props. Then, forget ‘em.”

  10. Psilokan.com » Class War funnies: 1935 Daily Worker comics Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 4:13 pm

    [...] Syd Hoff’s Teeth: The Leftist Satire of A. Redfield [...]

  11. Alexander Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 5:00 pm

    Have you ever seen how the dogma of the conservative strip “Mallard Fillmore” tends to get in the way of it, you know, actually having any humor?

    Same thing with this stuff. Attack propaganda for the sake of agenda, and to heck with being funny.

  12. Lee Bartell Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 5:07 pm

    As Yogi Berra said, it’s deja vu all over again. Damn, can’t we move on, evolve, and understand that we’re all related, are 50th cousins of each other, if not way closer. Maybe if we did, satirists would be out of work. OK, I get it, we need satirists, but who’re up to the calibre of Syd Hoff. Kudos to him.

  13. Peteykins Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 5:36 pm

    Ooh, I didn’t know about these! These are sharp.

    It shouldn’t be surprising that he praised Art Young, as Young was the most accomplished ultra-leftist cartoonist of the day, but also because Young would have been Hoff’s boss at the New Masses, so there is a smidgen of sucking-up involved.

  14. Syd Hoff’s Teeth: The Leftist Satire of A. Redfield « aepxc Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 6:06 pm

    [...] 30th, 2011 § Leave a Comment via philnel.com Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this [...]

  15. Freddd Said,

    October 30, 2011 @ 8:57 pm

    Thanks for explaining what each one means, great help.

  16. Poverty bugs me … | unemployedhack Said,

    October 31, 2011 @ 6:23 am

    [...] information on the images used in this post click here. Share this:MoreLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. This entry was posted in [...]

  17. A compilation of articles and videos regarding income inequality in the United States - Page 7 Said,

    November 1, 2011 @ 5:34 am

    [...] Cartoons from the 30's and 40's, that are still very relevant today. http://www.philnel.com/2011/02/02/hoff_teeth/ ____________________________ "War is a racket. It always has been. It is possibly the [...]

  18. Retratando a los ricos en tiempos de cólera. « Palomitas en los ojos Said,

    November 2, 2011 @ 6:01 am

    [...] donde daba rienda suelta a su crítica hiriente y mala baba y que dio como resultado el álbum “ The ruling Claws” que hacía un bonito juego de palabras entre “The Ruling Class” (La clase dirigente) y “The [...]

  19. Rabble-rousing political cartoons from the 1930′s | Politics in the Zeros Said,

    November 2, 2011 @ 8:47 pm

    [...] New Yorker and did the cartoons under a pseudonym for Daily Worker titling them The Ruling Clawss. Phil Nel has more. [...]

  20. Indignant Desert Birds » Sunday Morning Reading Material First Sunday in November 2011- Remember Remember Edition Said,

    November 6, 2011 @ 3:11 am

    [...] Class Warfare. Class Warfare never changes. I don’t mind when people have more money than I do. I don’t even mind when they have more money than I do and don’t work as hard. But the absolute sense that having more money makes someone a better human being? That’s the part I mind. That’s a lot of what the Occupy [city] protests are about. The only way to fix the problem is to create in America a genuine sense of Democracy. [...]

  21. ethan young Said,

    November 10, 2011 @ 12:59 am

    Art Young was never an editor at The New Masses.

    The cartoonists Hoff/Redfield singles out for criticism are onetime leftists like Soglow, or outright conservatives like Grey and Gould. In fact, Those two did vicious satirical work, but more in the guise of melodrama than comedy.

    Leftists still produce biting and hilarious satire. See the political cartoons in the London Guardian – way past what passes for ‘cutting edge’ on these shores.

  22. Philip Nel Said,

    November 10, 2011 @ 1:52 am

    True, Peteykins is incorrect in naming Art Young as Hoff’s “boss at New Masses.” Young and Hoff both contributed, but Crockett Johnson was the Art Editor of New Masses (from 1936 to 1940, anyway). Young was Editor of (and contributor to) the MassesNew Masses‘ predecessor. I use “predecessor” a bit loosely here. The Espionage Act shut down the Masses in December 1917, and The Liberator took its place in February 1918. In 1924, that publication merged with Workers’ Monthly. In 1925, ex-Masses and ex-Liberator writers formed New Masses.

  23. The Radical 1930s Cartoons Of Syd Hoff | Disinformation Said,

    November 10, 2011 @ 7:57 am

    [...] work with a harder-hitting tone for the Daily Worker and New Masses prior to World War II. Via Phil Nel, a collection of Hoff’s political cartoons, which remain as poignant and relevant as ever, in [...]

  24. A voice from the Dirty Thirties: The art of Syd Hoff | eats shoots 'n leaves Said,

    November 10, 2011 @ 7:26 pm

    [...] A voice from the Dirty Thirties: The art of Syd Hoff Posted on 2011 November 10 by richardbrenneman| Leave a comment After completing his day job doing cartoons for the New Yorker, Syd Hoff dipped his pen in acid to create some of the more memorable political cartoons of the1930s, the last time the global economy headed into the dumpster. Here’s an example, via Philip Nel’s blog, Nine Kinds of Pie: [...]

  25. Some Things Never Change | Left Perspectives Said,

    November 12, 2011 @ 5:18 pm

    [...] “While he was contributing to the New Yorker as Syd Hoff, he was also contributing to the Daily Worker and New Masses as A. Redfield — the pseudonym he adopted for his radical work.”  First displayed in the Daily Worker, a collection of his early cartoons was then published in the book, The Ruling Clawss (1935). Source and a few more of his cartoons [...]

  26. 30 bitingly satirical 1935 cartoons against the 1% - 22 Words Said,

    November 28, 2011 @ 2:31 pm

    [...] (Link to images, via Retronaut, Sad and Useless, Philip Nel) [...]

  27. 30 bitingly satirical 1935 cartoons against the 1% | Funri Said,

    November 28, 2011 @ 3:32 pm

    [...] (Link to images, via Retronaut, Sad and Useless, Philip Nel) [...]

Leave a Comment